News and views for the UB community
Published October 7, 2020
In the past year, popular uprisings have led to changes in governments in Algeria, Sudan and Puerto Rico. At the same time, the United States has used various methods to encourage or force regime change in Iran, Syria and Venezuela. Internal popular uprisings are often undertaken on pretexts of defending or extending human rights, but they can sometimes result in abuses of human rights. And calls for regime change in the name of “democracy” and “human rights” are often used to justify imperial intervention resulting in additional domestic repression.
To enhance understanding of the human rights dimensions of popular uprisings and regime change, experts from universities and non-governmental organizations will come together for a virtual symposium on Oct. 15.
Presenters will range from Suzanne Mettler, The John L. Senior Professor of American Institutions, Cornell University, to Jehanne Henry, associate director, Africa Division, Human Rights Watch.
The free, public event will take place from 9 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. — lunch break from 11 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. Registration is required; email dussourd@buffalo.edu to sign up.
The symposium honors the memory of Alison L. Des Forges, a member of the UB community who fought to call the world’s attention to another great humanitarian crisis: the genocide in Rwanda.
Des Forges, an internationally known historian and Buffalo native, was an adjunct member of the UB history faculty during the 1990s and received an honorary doctorate from SUNY during UB’s 155th general commencement ceremony in 2001.
She was one of the world’s leading experts on Rwanda, serving as an expert witness in 11 trials at the United Nations International Criminal Court for Rwanda. Her award-winning book, “Leave None to Tell the Story: Genocide in Rwanda,” was a landmark account of the 1994 genocide, and her tireless efforts to awaken the international community to the horrors that occurred earned her a MacArthur Fellowship in 1999.
The symposium will open at 9 a.m. with welcoming remarks, followed by panels focusing on “Collective Action and Human Rights on Three Continents” and “Political Change and Human Rights in Sudan.”
The “Collective Action and Human Rights” panel, which runs from 9-11:30 a.m., includes the following presentations:
Is American democracy in danger of backsliding today? Many assume that it is safe, given the nation’s long-standing Constitution and progress over time in granting more inclusive and extensive rights. Yet American history reveals that democracy has often been fragile: the nation has lurched through numerous periods wracked by uncertainty about whether war or secession was imminent, dictatorship might arise, or rights might be imperiled. Four threats have caused disruption: political polarization; conflict over who belongs, particularly along lines of race; economic inequality; and executive aggrandizement. Now, for the first time ever, Americans face the dangerous confluence of all four threats. Mettler will discuss what earlier crises and the settlements that emerged from them indicate about our circumstances today.
Africa has experienced a historic surge of protest in recent years. Some outsider observers fear that the unrest will destabilize African governments, amplify economic uncertainty and derail counterterrorism efforts. Others see encouraging possibilities for Africans to advance democracy, development and peace from below by pressuring incumbents for reforms. Policymakers from Western governments and development agencies are often ambivalent about whether to discourage protesters or support them with diplomatic and material aid. This presentation will offer policy-relevant analysis of the potential for African protesters to be reckless troublemakers or agents of positive change. It will also assess the practical and ethical risks of foreign intervention in domestic contentious politics.
This presentation will revisit Hong Kong’s anti-government protest from diverse political and economic perspectives. It will also compare how this protest was different from the previous movement, what made those differences, and how Hong Kong’s public perceives the movement.
The “Political Change and Human Rights in Sudan” panel, which runs from 12:30-2:30 p.m., includes the following presentations:
In June 1989, a secretive movement of Islamists allied itself to a military cabal to violently take power in Africa’s biggest country and launch a revolution meant to fundamentally overhaul the Sudanese state and the ways in which it engaged with the outside world. Sudan’s revolutionary regime was built on four pillars — a new politics, economic liberalization, an Islamic revival in society and a U-turn in foreign relations — and mixed militant conservatism with social engineering, a vision of authoritarian modernization. Over the three decades that the Al-Ingaz (Salvation) regime was in power, most outside attention focused on the many wars it fought in regions like Darfur, on the military-Islamist government’s relationship with Al-Qaeda and on its standoff with the U.S. and the West more broadly. But what such a focus has occluded has been the central importance of Sudan’s political economy and the ways in which the Al-Ingaz regime restructured state-society-market relations to entrench itself in power and organize new forms of social mobility while blocking others. This presentation focuses on socio-economic rights and the violence of development in Sudan — an exercise at once both retrospective and prospective, as Sudan’s post-April 2019 transitional institutions wrestle with the devastating economic legacies of three decades of Salvation rule.
Historic political changes are occurring in neighbors Ethiopia and Sudan, the Horn of Africa’s two largest countries. In both countries, mass popular uprisings precipitated these changes, although the processes of reform were different: Ethiopia’s 2018 shift occurred in the context of a leadership transition within the ruling political party, while Sudan saw an overthrow of most of the structures of the previous regime. Yet both countries remain vulnerable to the reversal of reforms, while continuing to provide each other with both models to potentially emulate as well as cautionary tales. This presentation will explore some of the key similarities and differences in contemporary Ethiopia and Sudan, discuss the implications and prospects for continuing reforms, and the future trajectory for the protection and enhancement of human rights.
Sudan’s 2018-19 people’s revolution was organized and led predominantly by youth and women’s groups from throughout the country, and represented a generational phenomenon of unprecedented breadth and depth. The upheaval it created, and its discipline and unwavering commitment to nonviolence shook the repressive regime of deposed President Omer al-Bashir, but it also took the traditional political and trade union opposition completely by surprise. Baldo’s presentation will focus on the mobilizing factors and demands of the youth and women’s groups behind the uprising. The presentation will in particular highlight the human rights and gender justice demands, and will assess the performance of the transitional authorities in realizing these demands of Sudan’s rising generations.
This presentation will focus on the protest movement, the violent and bloody crackdowns, the transitional government, and the struggle for justice by victims of the bloody crackdowns and other violations during al-Bashir’s regime in the year since the protests erupted. Henry will also discuss how Human Rights Watch researchers documented violations against protesters during the months leading up to al-Bashir’s ouster and following his ouster, as the Sudanese “street” kept up pressure on the transitional military council to hand power to civilians.
Symposium sponsors include the Alison Des Forges Memorial Committee; Jack Walsh; and the Baldy Center for Law and Social Policy, Confucius Institute, Department of Political Science, Gender Institute, Humanities Institute, James Agee Chair in American Culture and the Office of the Vice Provost for International Education, all from UB.
This is a very interesting topic.
Polina Burkhardt