U.S. Theoretical Physicists Organize To Stem 'Outsourcing'

BUFFALO, N.Y. -- Mention "outsourcing" and people tend to think of fields like manufacturing or telemarketing; theoretical physics isn't even on the list.

Yet the scientists who develop theoretical predictions for high-energy particle physics experiments say "outsourcing" in their field has allowed the U.S. to lag behind in this area of high-profile, global science.

"This is the wrong kind of outsourcing," says Ulrich Baur, Ph.D., professor of physics in the University at Buffalo College of Arts and Sciences and a co-founder of the Large Hadron Collider-Theory Initiative (http://www.lhc-ti.org).

LHC-TI is a consortium of theoretical physicists whose goal is to train more U.S. graduate students in theoretical high-energy particle physics calculations relevant to the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) being built near Geneva, Switzerland.

"We are behind the Europeans and we believe very strongly that we shouldn't just leave this work to the Europeans," Baur says.

After several years of grass-roots organizing among theoretical physicsts, the group is celebrating success: the awarding of the first LHC Theory Graduate Fellowship Awards, funded by the National Science Foundation and administered by The Johns Hopkins University.

According to Baur, a co-principal investigator on the program, this prestigious fellowship structure will cultivate and support young theoretical physicists who will then go on to fill faculty positions at American universities.

The awards, he added, will begin to build up the pool of talent that began to decline following Congress' 1993 decision not to build the Superconducting Super Collider in Waxahachie, Texas.

"The demise of the SSC was a blow to high-energy physics in the U.S.," says Baur, who was an SSC Fellow in 1991 along with some of his colleagues on the LHC Theory Initiative. "It may have

contributed to this decline in that theorists decided to work on more speculative topics, such as string theory."

Funding in the U.S. for particle physics as a whole and theoretical particle physics, in particular, has declined significantly over the past 15 years, Baur says.

In addition, he says, physics departments in U.S. universities tend to hire faculty members who develop innovative ideas, whereas in Europe the physics culture equally emphasizes novel research and solid calculations that help advance the field as a whole.

But with the Large Hadron Collider, the world's largest particle accelerator, coming online in the next year or sooner, Baur explains, the U.S. cannot afford to fall behind.

"With the potential of the LHC for making breakthrough discoveries, the U.S. cannot afford not to play a leadership role in LHC-related theory," Baur and Lynne Orr, Ph.D., a physics professor at the University of Rochester, warned in a 2005 memo to fellow theorists.

Baur, Orr and others in their field had recognized that the contributions of American scientists in the field of LHC-related, high-energy physics theory were insufficient because there simply were not enough young theoretical physicists pursuing these calculations.

"In order for the LHC to properly deliver results, there is a strong need for accurate theoretical predictions about the experiments that will be done there," says Baur. "While the U.S. has been very strongly involved in building detectors for experimental efforts, there hasn't been a whole lot of work going on with the theory side."

The LHC, a $4 billion accelerator, will demand a groundswell of new theoretical predictions. That's because it will be capable of exploring a new energy domain almost an order of magnitude above the energy scale accessible with currently available accelerators, Baur explains.

In 2005, he and Orr began what they call a "community-driven process" to draw attention to the need to train more theoretical physicists in the U.S. with town meetings held at scientific conferences around the nation.

"We tried to rally the field," said Baur.

This year, the efforts of the group paid off with the establishment by NSF of the Large Hadron Collider Theory Initiative. Jonathan A. Bagger, Ph.D., professor of physics and astronomy at The Johns Hopkins University, is principal investigator on the grant and Baur, Orr and R. Sekhar Chivukula, Ph.D., at Michigan State University, are co-investigators.

In April, the nationally competitive program announced its first two awards of $40,000 each to two theoretical physics students to underwrite their research, travel and computing needs. Four additional graduate students received $3,000 travel awards.

Beginning next year, the LHC Theory Initiative plans to award $150,000 postdoctoral grants to pursue LHC-related research and build a network of LHC-related theorists in the U.S.

"We want to create a strong community of young physicists," says Baur.

For more information on the LHC Theory Initiative, please go to http://www.lhc-ti.org.

The University at Buffalo is a premier research-intensive public university, the largest and most comprehensive campus in the State University of New York. UB's more than 27,000 students pursue their academic interests through more than 300 undergraduate, graduate and professional degree programs. Founded in 1846, the University at Buffalo is a member of the Association of American Universities.