This article is from the archives of the UB Reporter.
Archives

Analyzing bottlenecks in chemical reactions

UB researchers are using supercomputers to increase accuracy of calculations

Published: February 20, 2003

By ELLEN GOLDBAUM
Contributing Editor

Harry King thinks a lot about traffic jams and bottlenecks, but not the kind that most of us experience in our daily commutes. The UB chemistry professor's focus is on chemical bottlenecks, the kinds of jams that may control the overall rate of a complex series of chemical reactions.

His goal is to determine with greater accuracy the nature of the bottlenecks, ultimately providing scientists with a far greater comprehension of important reactions, allowing them to better control them. Fields that are expected to benefit from these understandings range from atmospheric chemistry to automotive engine design. When it comes to understanding the spectrum of chemical reactions, King says highly accurate data are needed for just a few key reactions.

photo

Harry King

"Just as there are multiple routes that will get you from UB to Kleinhans Hall near downtown Buffalo, there are multiple ways to get from reactants to products," explains King. "Molecules may encounter minor traffic jams while approaching and leaving the bottleneck, but these are of little importance compared with the time it takes to get through the one particular elementary reaction that has a high-energy barrier, the bottleneck."

Identifying accurate rates for these key reactions, which involve the breaking of a chemical bond and the formation of a new one, is critical. During a chemical reaction, King notes that molecules go through a transition state.

"To predict the speed of the reaction, one needs to know the shape and energy of the molecule in the transition state," says King. That's easier said than done, however.

Even using state-of-the-art experimental techniques, it is usually impossible to observe molecules going through the transition state since they exist in that state only for a fraction of an instant. However, by executing extremely complex calculations based on the theory of quantum mechanics, King says, supercomputers allow computational chemists to predict the energy and structure of these important, but fleeting intermediate molecules or molecular fragments.

"As computational chemists, we treat molecules like mechanical systems that consist of particles, nuclei, electrons, in order to examine the mathematical relationships among them," explains King. "If you can 'solve' those relationships, then you could, in principle, answer almost any question."

He notes, however, that scientists never really solve these equations. "We always make mathematical approximations," he explains. "These approximations have gotten awfully good over the past few years, but we'd like to make them even better."

With funding from the National Science Foundation, King and his colleagues at UB are developing a method that they hope will make those approximations from 10 to 100 times more accurate, a goal they hope to attain more quickly, thanks to the power of the cluster of Dell computers in UB's Center for Computational Research.

As a first test of the new method, the UB team is studying a simple molecule composed of two carbon atoms. This molecule has the distinction of being a stable molecule, so it can be studied in the laboratory, and it also has many similarities to the fleeting intermediate species that occur in the very short-lived transition state that chemists long to study.

"The diatomic carbon molecule has a lot in common with a typical transition state, but it's a stable molecule, so we picked it out as a nice test case," says King. "Yet even with such a simple molecule, this problem is too big to run on a single processor.

Marek Freindorf, UB postdoctoral research scientist and a member of King's team, has found that it takes several days to complete one run using a dozen processors on one of CCR's parallel computers.

"On the new Dell cluster, instead of taking several days, it takes just a few hours," King observes.

In order to solve all of the equations related to the dissociation of the two carbon atoms, the UB team developed a mathematical expression called a wave function that contains a whopping 140 million terms.

Their findings generated on the Dell computer cluster will be compared to the findings obtained by laboratory spectroscopic analyses, which measure the diatomic carbon molecule. This brings the UB team closer to developing a robust method that would allow scientists to figure out quickly the few terms that are critical to determining the reaction rate and the mechanisms for a particular reaction. As for how long it will be before the team develops such a method, King estimates it could take just a few years.

"Between the calculations we're making using the supercomputers and the observations that have been made in the lab," he says, "we're getting fantastically good agreement."